Why Do Companies Use the Health Care Personnel Handwash Study to Evaluate their Products? - Bioscience Labs
1765 South 19th Ave Bozeman, MT    
877-858-2754

Why Do Companies Use the Health Care Personnel Handwash Study to Evaluate their Products?

Posted On: May 03, 2016

Written by Dr. Daryl Paulson, MBA, President & CEO
experts@biosciencelabs.com

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulates the healthcare industry, and one of the requirements for a healthcare personnel handwash requires manufacturers to prove their products are effective in the reduction of bacteria. That reduction needs to be a 2.0 log10 reduction in bacteria on human skin after one wash and a 3.0 log10 reduction in bacteria after ten washes.

A healthcare personnel handwash is designed to reduce the number of transient, potentially pathogenic microorganisms “picked up” from the environment on countertops, other people’s hands, door handles, and just touching. We can see that a product degerms the hands, but what exactly is that?

Let us first look at the hands from a microscopic perspective to see and understand how the skin functions in terms of handwash products (Figure 1).

Figure 1. Contaminated Hands (From a Microscopic View)

There are two general types of microorganisms that reside on the skin, permanently and temporarily:

  • The blue represents the resident bacteria (Staphylococcus epidermidis and others, such as Enterobacteriaceae species) that normally live on the skin surface. These are not dangerous bacteria for one’s own or others’ health, as long as the skin is not punctured or otherwise compromised. In fact, they keep pathogens – disease-causing bacteria – from establishing a niche on the skin surfaces.
  • The red represents the transient bacteria, which are the bacteria of interest in this discussion, for they can cause illnesses. They are picked up on the hand surfaces from the environment during the course of the day, by doing things like shaking hands, touching doors, flushing toilets, etc., associated with everyday living.
Transient Bacteria

These are the bacteria, fungi, molds and viruses that do not reside on a person’s skin surfaces naturally. They are picked up on a person’s hands when an individual touches something – a sink, a door, another person’s hands, or by coughing into one’s hands.

This leads to contamination.

When the hands are contaminated by transient microorganisms, the resident bacteria prevent them from establishing a niche. Yet, while they are on the hands, they can be exposed to a great many people and become a serious threat.

Note that all the contaminant bacteria that one picks up are not dangerous, but many can cause infections.

In the foodhandler arena, these microorganisms can be transmitted from an employee to a large number of people buying processed food. In the healthcare field, they can be picked up by a physician or nurse and passed on to a patient, who then passes them on to others.

Resident Bacteria

The deeper bacteria, the resident ones, normally live on the skin surfaces or throughout the skin squames and provide a unique and valuable contribution to the protection of the person. As long as those bacteria are present, an individual’s skin ecology remains in equilibrium. If they are removed or killed, then more hostile microorganisms, such as fungi, can cause severe skin infections. So it is better that we do not kill or completely remove them.

It is the transient bacteria that can cause disease quite readily for a short time, until they are killed by the resident microorganisms. These transient bacteria are the ones in which we are interested.

What types of products are used to eliminate these transient bacteria?

Alcohol products are very effective against transient bacteria. They were not used in the past because they dried the skin. When skin emollients were added, they became very popular because of their effectiveness and versatility, as they can be applied with or without water. Alcohol products kill the transient and some resident bacteria immediately, but when they dry, the products have no residual antimicrobial properties and do not generally affect the remaining resident bacteria.

Washing the hands with soap and water is effective, as well as using chlorhexidine gluconate (CHG), iodine, triclosan and other products. Iodine and CHG products, however, are generally considered too strong for this application, as they can chap the hands from prolonged use. Iodine and CHG products are designed, instead, to degerm the resident flora for surgical scrubs or preoperative preparation evaluations.

When there are two types of bacteria, transient and resident, residing on the skin, how can we know that we are removing the transient, disease-causing bacteria?

The procedure, according to FDA guidelines, is to use Serratia marcescens, as the marker organisms, because it has a red interior color. This identifies them as the transient bacteria, rather than looking at resident bacterial, like Staphylococcus epidermidis and other normal microorganisms, which appear white or yellowish on the plates. In the FDA-approved healthcare personnel handwash procedure, the red colonies, or the transient bacteria, are counted, and the resident bacteria (white or yellowish) are not counted.

By contaminating the hands with a specific level of microorganisms (i.e., the initial population), we can measure the baseline count. A marker organism, such as Serratia marcescens, is used, because it can be distinguished by color. After the antimicrobial product is applied, the glove juice sampling procedure is performed to measure how many microorganisms remain. Knowing the beginning measurement of microorganisms allows researchers to determine how many microorganisms were killed by the product.

The bacteria is applied to the hands multiple times to simulate the number of times a healthcare worker might use the antimicrobial soap product on a daily basis to clean the hands. Each time the marker organism is added or the hands are washed, the glove juice sampling procedure is used. Serial dilutions are made, and samples are plated and incubated.

After the samples have been plated and incubated for approximately 24 hours, the plates are counted to see if the product(s) sufficiently killed the bacteria that was placed on the hands. As long as appropriate neutralizers were used in the collection of samples, the data collected from this test is a good indicator that the product helps control and/or prevent transient and resident microorganisms from spreading.

In conclusion, the FDA has mandated that a healthcare personnel handwash is an important test to help manufactures create effective products that help prevent the spread of disease via transient organisms.